Herzberg's Two-Factor Theory
The things that make people satisfied at work are different from the things that make them dissatisfied.
What it is
Herzberg found that job satisfaction and dissatisfaction are not opposite ends of one scale. One group of factors causes dissatisfaction when absent but does not motivate when present. A separate group produces real motivation.
Fixing the first group removes complaints. Only the second makes people want to do the work.
When to use it
When pay rises and perks have not improved engagement, or when redesigning jobs.
The two factors
- Hygiene factors Pay, job security, working conditions, company policy and supervision. They prevent dissatisfaction.Ask: Are pay, conditions and policies causing complaints?
- Motivators Achievement, recognition, responsibility, advancement and the work itself. They create satisfaction.Ask: Does the work offer achievement and recognition?
- Job enrichment Build motivators into the job by adding responsibility, autonomy and a complete piece of work.Ask: Can the job be given more responsibility?
Example
An engineering team gets a pay increase and a new office, and complaints stop, but output is unchanged. When engineers are given ownership of features from design to release, both engagement and delivery improve.
How to run it
- Survey what dissatisfies and what motivates, separately.
- Fix the hygiene problems first.
- Then build motivators into the work itself.
- Do not expect pay alone to motivate.
Limits
The findings depend partly on the interview method used: people credit themselves for good experiences and blame circumstances for bad ones. Pay can motivate some people in some roles.